Planning the perfect Valentine’s Day dinner in New York City can be exciting and daunting, given the many dining options available. To help you curate an unforgettable evening, I’ve compiled a list of the top 21 restaurants in NYC that offer exceptional Valentine’s Day experiences. Each venue has been selected based on ambiance, cuisine, and unique offerings to cater to various preferences.
Top 21 Valentine’s Day Restaurants In NYC
#1. Gage & Tollner – Timeless Romance in a Historic Setting
📍 Location: 372 Fulton St, Downtown Brooklyn
💰 Pricing: $185 per person
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: If you’re looking for a classic, old-school romantic dining experience, Gage & Tollner delivers with its rich history, intimate lighting, and outstanding service. This 19th-century chophouse is one of Brooklyn’s most iconic restaurants, making it an elegant spot for Valentine’s Day.
The Valentine’s Day menu features yellowtail crudo, she-crab soup, braised lamb, and a signature baked Alaska for dessert. The cocktail menu is just as impressive, featuring expertly crafted classics and signature drinks.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#2. Loreley Beer Garden – Cozy & Festive Valentine’s Atmosphere
📍 Location: 7 Rivington St, Lower East Side
💰 Pricing: À la carte (estimated $50–$80 per person)
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: If you prefer a casual yet romantic setting, Loreley Beer Garden transforms into a Valentine’s wonderland with 10,000 red rose petals covering tables and their Winter Lodge theme creating a warm, cozy vibe.
The a la carte Valentine’s menu includes heart-shaped pretzels, Cupid’s espresso martinis, and festive Valentine’s cocktails. They also have a special happy hour from 5–7 PM, making this a great spot for a fun and relaxed date.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#3. L’Artusi – Italian Elegance & Candlelit Romance
📍 Location: 228 W 10th St, Greenwich Village
💰 Pricing: $175 per person
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: This intimate, chic Italian restaurant is perfect for couples looking for a mix of romance and casual sophistication. With exposed brick walls, dim lighting, and an extensive wine selection, L’Artusi is one of the most sought-after Valentine’s Day dinner spots in NYC.
Their special Valentine’s menu features handmade pasta with truffles, slow-roasted chicken, grilled seafood, and a chocolate hazelnut tart. Pair it with a bottle of Italian red wine for a truly indulgent experience.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#4. The Modern – Michelin-Starred Dining with Artful Ambiance
📍 Location: 9 W 53rd St, Midtown Manhattan
💰 Pricing: $295 per person
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: The Modern offers an ultra-sophisticated fine-dining experience with views of MoMA’s stunning sculpture garden. This Michelin-starred restaurant is ideal for couples who appreciate contemporary art, refined cuisine, and impeccable service.
Their Valentine’s Day tasting menu features caviar, foie gras, black truffle pasta, dry-aged beef, and a stunning chocolate soufflé. The wine-pairing experience is available for an additional $150.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#5. Hortus NYC – Chic, Upscale & Globally Inspired
📍 Location: 271 5th Ave, Midtown Manhattan
💰 Pricing: $145 per person
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: If you want a modern dining experience with flavors from around the world, Hortus NYC is an excellent choice. Their sleek and intimate atmosphere, paired with a refined fusion menu, makes for a sophisticated Valentine’s experience.
Their prix-fixe Valentine’s menu includes tuna tartare, Korean-style wagyu, truffle scallops, and a selection of handcrafted desserts. They also offer an impressive sake and wine selection to elevate your evening.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#6. One If By Land, Two If By Sea – The Ultimate Romantic Classic
📍 Location: 17 Barrow St, West Village
💰 Pricing: $350 per person
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: Often ranked as one of NYC’s most romantic restaurants, One If By Land, Two If By Sea is a candlelit dream, complete with roaring fireplaces and an elegant ambiance. If you’re looking for a truly unforgettable Valentine’s Day dinner, this is the spot.
Their five-course Valentine’s tasting menu includes lobster bisque, duck confit, filet mignon, and a decadent chocolate soufflé. The wine list is extensive, making it perfect for wine lovers looking for the ultimate fine-dining experience.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#7. The Landing – A Hidden Gem for Surf & Turf Lovers
📍 Location: 383 W 31st St, Chelsea
Pricing: $165 per person
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: If you’re looking for a great steak and seafood Valentine’s dinner near Madison Square Garden and Penn Station, The Landing offers a luxurious yet relaxed atmosphere.
Their Surf & Turf Valentine’s Day Special includes a 24 oz porterhouse steak, grilled lobster tail, truffle mashed potatoes, and a rich crème brûlée. It’s the perfect spot for meat lovers who want a high-quality meal without pretentiousness.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#8. ABC Kitchen – Organic, Sustainable & Intimate Dining
📍 Location: 35 E 18th St, Gramercy
💰 Pricing: $160 per person
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: If you and your partner appreciate farm-to-table dining, ABC Kitchen is a fantastic choice. Their Valentine’s Day menu focuses on fresh, locally sourced ingredients in a beautiful, rustic-chic setting.
Expect dishes like wood-fired roasted scallops, handmade ricotta gnocchi, organic ribeye steak, and an elegant strawberry shortcake. Their cocktail menu is excellent, featuring creative drinks made with fresh, seasonal ingredients.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#9. Nerai – Romantic Greek Fine Dining
📍 Location: 55 E 54th St, Midtown East
💰 Pricing: $140 per person
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: If you’re in the mood for Greek fine dining with a modern twist, Nerai is an excellent pick. The cozy yet upscale ambiance, combined with their flavorful Mediterranean menu, creates an ideal romantic setting.
The four-course Valentine’s menu includes black bass crudo, king crab, squid ink pasta with Maine lobster, seared scallops, and fillet mignon. Their wine list includes an impressive selection of Greek and international wines.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#10. Mastro’s Steakhouse – Luxury Steak & Seafood Experience
📍 Location: 1285 6th Ave, Midtown Manhattan
💰 Pricing: $200 per person
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: For steak and seafood lovers, Mastro’s offers a luxurious dining experience in an elegant setting. With live music, dim lighting, and white-tablecloth service, this is a perfect spot for a fancy Valentine’s dinner.
The special menu includes butter-aged filet mignon, Alaskan king crab legs, black truffle mashed potatoes, and a signature butter cake for dessert. Cocktails and wines are top-tier, making it an ideal place for a high-end date night.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#11. The River Café – Breathtaking Views & Fine Dining
📍 Location: 1 Water St, Brooklyn Heights
💰 Pricing: $225 per person
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: If you’re looking for one of the most romantic dining experiences in NYC, The River Café is unmatched. Nestled under the Brooklyn Bridge, it offers stunning views of the Manhattan skyline, live piano music, and an award-winning fine dining experience.
Kumamoto oysters, beef Wellington, butter-poached lobster, and a legendary chocolate Brooklyn Bridge dessert are all included in the Valentine’s Day prix-fixe menu. This spot is perfect for couples who love luxury and unforgettable views.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#12. Manhatta – Sky-High Romance with Stunning City Views
📍 Location: 28 Liberty St, 60th Floor, Financial District
💰 Pricing: $195 per person
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: Panoramic skyline views and exquisite cuisine come together at Manhatta, one of the most sought-after fine dining spots in NYC. With floor-to-ceiling windows offering breathtaking views of the city, this restaurant is a top-tier choice for a Valentine’s Day dinner.
Their Valentine’s Day menu features foie gras terrine, black truffle risotto, dry-aged duck, and a rich passionfruit dessert. A wine-pairing experience is also available for an additional $90.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#13. Le Coucou – Elegant French Cuisine in SoHo
📍 Location: 138 Lafayette St, SoHo
💰 Pricing: $250 per person
Why You’ll Love It: Le Coucou offers a classic Parisian-inspired Valentine’s dinner that is sure to impress. The chic interior, soft candlelight, and white tablecloths set the mood for a sophisticated evening.
Their prix-fixe menu includes lobster bisque, roasted duck with orange glaze, and a delicate raspberry mille-feuille. The wine list is extensive, featuring some of the best French selections in NYC.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#14. Maison Premiere – Oysters & Absinthe in a Vintage Setting
📍 Location: 298 Bedford Ave, Williamsburg, Brooklyn
💰 Pricing: $140 per person
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: If you and your partner love classic New Orleans charm, oyster platters, and absinthe cocktails, Maison Premiere is a fantastic pick. The intimate candlelit setting and vintage décor create an incredibly romantic vibe.
The Valentine’s Day special includes a curated oyster tasting, grilled scallops, slow-braised short ribs, and a decadent chocolate torte. This is the ideal place for a cozy, intimate dinner with a vintage feel.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#15. Daniel – Michelin-Starred Luxury Dining
📍 Location: 60 E 65th St, Upper East Side
💰 Pricing: $350 per person
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: One of the most prestigious fine dining restaurants in NYC, Daniel is a Michelin-starred institution known for its lavish tasting menu and impeccable service.
For Valentine’s Day, expect a seven-course tasting experience featuring caviar, butter-poached lobster, aged wagyu beef, and a stunning dessert selection. The wine pairing option costs an additional $150 per person, perfect for a luxurious dining experience.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#16. The Nines – Live Jazz & Fine Dining
📍 Location: 9 Great Jones St, NoHo
💰 Pricing: $150 per person
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: The Nines is a sophisticated, jazz-infused dining lounge perfect for a sultry Valentine’s Day experience. With dim lighting, plush velvet seating, and live piano music, this is a spot for couples who love romance with a side of old-school glamour.
Their Valentine’s Day prix-fixe menu includes an oyster and caviar starter, filet mignon with black truffle butter, and a decadent dark chocolate fondant. Pair it with their signature champagne cocktail or espresso martini for the ultimate experience.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#17. Hart’s – Cozy Mediterranean-Inspired Dining
📍 Location: 506 Franklin Ave, Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn
💰 Pricing: $85 per person
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: If you and your partner prefer an intimate, neighborhood vibe, Hart’s offers a charming atmosphere, candlelit tables, and a warm, rustic menu.
The Valentine’s Day special includes grilled oysters, roasted lamb with harissa, and their famous olive oil cake. Pair it with a natural wine selection from their curated list for a perfect evening.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#18. Lilia – Handmade Italian Pastas in a Minimalist Setting
📍 Location: 567 Union Ave, Williamsburg, Brooklyn
💰 Pricing: $125 per person
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: Lilia is one of the most sought-after Italian restaurants in NYC, famous for its handmade pastas and wood-fired seafood.
Their Valentine’s Day menu features ricotta-stuffed agnolotti, grilled scallops, and a rich olive oil cake with mascarpone. The ambiance is modern yet warm, making it perfect for a relaxed but refined date night.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#19. Monkey Bar – Classic New York Romance
📍 Location: 60 E 54th St, Midtown Manhattan
💰 Pricing: $135 per person
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: If you love classic New York vibes with an Art Deco twist, Monkey Bar is a perfectly nostalgic spot for Valentine’s Day. With its low-lit, intimate atmosphere and red leather booths, this is a timeless choice for romance.
The prix-fixe menu includes oysters Rockefeller, roasted duck, and a red velvet soufflé for dessert. Live music performances add to the ambiance, making this a must-visit spot.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#20. Clover Club – Romantic Cocktails & Jazz
📍 Location: 210 Smith St, Cobble Hill, Brooklyn
💰 Pricing: $90 per person
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: If you’re looking for a low-key yet elegant Valentine’s date night, Clover Club offers an incredible cocktail menu, cozy seating, and a sophisticated atmosphere.
Their Valentine’s Day specials include charcuterie boards, duck confit, and their signature champagne cocktail. Perfect for couples who love a romantic speakeasy vibe.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
#21. Il Buco – Old-World Italian Charm
📍 Location: 47 Bond St, NoHo
💰 Pricing: $140 per person
🌟 Why You’ll Love It: For couples who adore classic, rustic Italian cuisine, Il Buco provides a warm, intimate setting with candlelit tables and an incredible wine selection.
The Valentine’s Day menu features house-made pasta with black truffles, grilled branzino, and a rich tiramisu for dessert. This is a perfect romantic hideaway in the heart of the city.
🍽️ Reservations: Book here
Key Takeaways
- NYC offers a variety of romantic restaurants for Valentine’s Day, ranging from cozy wine bars to Michelin-starred fine dining experiences.
- Reservations are essential, especially for high-demand spots like Le Coucou, The River Café, and Daniel.
- Budget and ambiance matter—whether you prefer a casual bistro, a rooftop view, or an intimate candlelit setting, there’s a restaurant to match your style.
- Consider a prix-fixe menu for a curated dining experience, as many restaurants offer special Valentine’s Day selections.
- Don’t forget extra touches like flowers, champagne, or a post-dinner stroll through Central Park to make the evening unforgettable.
Conclusion
Valentine’s Day in New York City offers a unique experience, and choosing the right restaurant can transform it into an unforgettable evening. Whether you’re looking for a luxurious fine dining spot, a cozy hidden gem, or a vibrant and trendy atmosphere, NYC has something for every couple. Which of these top Valentine’s Day restaurants are you most excited to try?
Related Articles
